Panic Disorder Case Study: 33-Year-Old Pharmacist from Kalyan Whose Panic Attacks Were Mistaken for Heart Attacks and Who Began Avoiding the Local Train
Facing something similar? Talk to us.
Get a free, no-obligation consultation. Our clinical team will guide you or your family to the right plan.
Panic Disorder Case Study: Patient Background
This panic disorder case study follows Neha (name changed), a composite example that reflects how panic attacks can be mistaken for a heart problem, how avoidance builds up around them, and how panic disorder is assessed and treated at Calida Rehab. The details are illustrative and do not describe any one identifiable person.
Neha is a 33-year-old pharmacist who works at a hospital pharmacy in Thane. She lives in Kalyan with her husband and travels to work by local train. She has always been a careful, responsible person who plans ahead. Eight months before she came to us, she was in a crowded morning train when her heart began to pound, her chest tightened, her hands tingled and she felt sure she was about to die. She got off at the next station, sat on a platform bench shaking and drenched in sweat, and a fellow passenger helped her reach a nearby hospital emergency room. Her ECG and blood tests were normal. The doctor told her it was “only anxiety”, gave her a strip of alprazolam to use when needed, and sent her home.
It happened again two weeks later, this time at home at night, when she woke from sleep with her heart racing. Over the next months she had three emergency room visits, an echocardiogram, a 24-hour heart rhythm recording and a cardiologist’s opinion, all normal. Each time she was reassured, and each time the relief lasted only days. She began to check her pulse on her smartwatch many times a day. She stopped taking the train, shifted to a longer bus-and-auto route that added nearly two hours to her day, avoided lifts and crowded markets, and asked her husband to come with her whenever she went out. She was using the alprazolam three or four times a week, and she was drinking five to six cups of strong tea and coffee a day to get through the day. Her work shifts were cut, and she told us she felt “afraid of my own body”.
Her husband brought her to our centre after a fourth attack at a family wedding. Before the case itself, a short note. A panic attack is a sudden surge of intense fear that peaks within minutes and comes with strong body symptoms. Panic disorder is diagnosed when attacks keep coming without a clear trigger and the person lives in fear of the next one or changes their life to avoid it. Panic attacks are frightening but not dangerous in themselves, yet chest pain, a racing heart and breathlessness must always be checked by a doctor first. To read more, see our panic disorder page and our anxiety case study.
Symptoms: How Panic Disorder Showed Up in Neha
A panic attack comes in a wave, builds quickly and usually passes within about 20 to 30 minutes, though it can feel far longer. Neha had the following during her attacks, and also in the time between them.
During a panic attack:
- A pounding or racing heart, and tightness or pain in the chest
- Shortness of breath, a feeling of choking, and fast breathing
- Sweating, trembling, and hot or cold flushes
- Dizziness, light-headedness, and tingling or numbness in the hands, face and lips
- Nausea or a churning stomach
- A feeling of unreality or of being detached from her surroundings
- A strong fear of dying, of having a heart attack, of fainting or of “going mad”
Between attacks:
- Constant worry about when the next attack would come (anticipatory anxiety)
- Checking her pulse and chest many times a day, and noticing every flutter
- Avoiding the local train, lifts, crowded markets and being far from home or a hospital
- Needing her husband with her, sitting near doors and carrying a water bottle “just in case” (safety behaviours)
- Poor sleep, with waking at night and a racing heart
- Tiredness, irritability and some low mood as her world became smaller
Behind the picture was a cycle that kept itself going:
- A normal body sensation, such as a skipped beat or a rush of heat, was noticed and read as danger.
- The fear made her heart race and her breathing quicken, which made the sensations stronger.
- The stronger sensations seemed to prove that something was seriously wrong, and the fear rose into a panic attack.
- Avoidance, checking and tablets brought short relief, but they taught her brain that the danger was real, so the fear came back stronger.
Why Panic Attacks Are Often Mistaken for Heart Attacks
Panic disorder is common and is often mistaken for a heart problem, especially in the first months. Looking back with Neha and her husband, the team found several reasons, and none of them were anyone’s fault alone.
- The symptoms feel like a heart attack. Chest pain, a racing heart, sweating and breathlessness are exactly the signs people are taught to fear, so going to the emergency room is the right first step.
- Normal tests bring only brief relief. A normal ECG shows that the heart is healthy, but the person may think “they missed something” and look for another test.
- “It’s only anxiety” does not explain anything. Without a clear explanation of how panic works and how it is treated, the person stays afraid and may not seek the right help.
- Avoidance looks sensible. Skipping the train or the lift feels like a reasonable choice, so the problem can grow for months before anyone sees a pattern.
- Tablets can hide the problem. Taking a sedative whenever panic strikes brings quick relief, but it can keep the fear alive and, with regular use, lead to dependence.
Diagnosis: How Panic Disorder Was Assessed
There is no blood test or scan for panic disorder. The diagnosis is made by a psychiatrist from the history, an examination and tests that rule out other causes. Because her symptoms involved the heart and breathing, we first made sure that nothing medical had been missed. For Neha, our team gathered the following:
- A detailed history from Neha and her husband: how the first attack began, how often attacks came, whether they came without warning, what she feared would happen, what she had started to avoid and how her life had changed.
- A review of her earlier medical reports: two ECGs, an echocardiogram, a 24-hour heart rhythm recording and her cardiologist’s opinion, all normal. We did not repeat them. Her thyroid function, blood sugar, blood count and electrolytes were also normal.
- A physical examination: pulse, blood pressure and breathing, to confirm that she was well.
- A review of what she took and drank: five to six cups of strong tea and coffee a day, and alprazolam three or four times a week. Caffeine, some medicines, alcohol and drug withdrawal can all cause or worsen panic.
- The Panic Disorder Severity Scale (PDSS): a score of 18 out of 28, showing frequent attacks, strong fear of the next one and clear avoidance.
- GAD-7 and PHQ-9 screening: a GAD-7 score of 13 for anxiety and a PHQ-9 score of 8 for low mood, which was mild and linked to her shrinking life.
- An avoidance review: she avoided trains, lifts and crowded places and rarely went out alone, which met the criteria for agoraphobia alongside her panic disorder.
- A review for other conditions: health anxiety, social anxiety, post-traumatic stress, depression, substance use and thyroid disease, none of which explained the picture on their own.
The team’s conclusion was panic disorder with agoraphobia, with mild low mood, and with caffeine and alprazolam use that were keeping the cycle going. No medical cause was found. The aims were to explain the panic cycle clearly, to treat the panic and the avoidance, to reduce the caffeine and sedative use safely and to help Neha get back to her train, her work and her independence.
Treatment Plan for Panic Disorder
The core of treatment for panic disorder is cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) with gradual exposure to the feared body sensations and situations, with a medicine added where needed. Neha stayed with us for 10 days for assessment, the start of medicine and the first stage of therapy, and then went home with a follow-up plan and weekly review sessions. We treat panic disorder at our mental hospital in Mumbai, where psychiatrists and therapists work together on each person’s care. Her plan had these parts.
- A clear explanation of panic: in the first week the psychiatrist used her own ECG and reports to show why a panic attack is not a heart attack, and drew the cycle of sensation, fear and avoidance with her.
- An antidepressant medicine: a selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor (SSRI) started at a low dose by the psychiatrist and raised slowly. We told her to expect a few restless days at the start and a benefit over four to six weeks.
- A plan for the alprazolam: benzodiazepines can calm an attack, but regular use keeps avoidance alive and can lead to dependence. Under the psychiatrist’s guidance she moved to taking it only on set days and then reduced it step by step until she stopped. She did not stop it suddenly. See our case study on benzodiazepine addiction.
- 12 weekly CBT sessions: with her own therapist, focused on understanding panic, facing the body sensations and returning to the places she avoided.
- Caffeine reduction: from six cups to one or two a day over two weeks, with the last cup before late afternoon.
- Sleep and activity: fixed sleep and waking times, and a daily 30-minute walk, which helped her body get used to a raised heart rate.
- A family plan: her husband learned to support her without taking over, which meant not driving her everywhere and not answering every “what if”.
- A gradual return to work: with agreed targets for her shifts and her commute, shared with her supervisor with her consent.
Call our 24-hour free confidential helpline.
Treatments
Your recovery story can start today.
Speak to our clinical team in confidence. We are available 24x7.
Therapies Used in This Panic Disorder Case Study
The therapies below were part of Neha’s plan. They were short, practical and built around practice between sessions.
- Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT): helped her to spot the thought “this is a heart attack”, to test it against the evidence and to replace it with “this is a panic wave and it will pass”. See our cognitive behavioural therapy page.
- Interoceptive exposure: in session she deliberately brought on the body sensations she feared, such as spinning in a chair, breathing fast for one minute and running on the spot, until they stopped frightening her. This is a key step in panic treatment.
- Graded exposure to situations: a ladder of steps from sitting on a station platform to a full peak-hour journey, with each step repeated until the fear fell. See our exposure therapy page.
- Dropping safety behaviours: step by step she stopped checking her pulse, carrying a water bottle everywhere, sitting by the door and asking for reassurance.
- Psychoeducation: plain teaching for Neha and her husband about the panic cycle, why fast breathing causes tingling and dizziness, and why avoidance makes panic stronger. See our psychoeducation page.
- Slow breathing and mindfulness practice: used for general calm and sleep, and not as a way to escape a panic attack. See our mindfulness-based cognitive therapy page.
- Family therapy: helped her husband, who had become her driver and her source of reassurance, to step back kindly and to cheer her on. See our family therapy page.
- Group therapy: sessions with others who had panic attacks, which helped her to see that she was not alone and not “going mad”. See our group therapy page.
Follow-Up Care After Treatment
Panic disorder can return under stress, so Neha’s aftercare was written down before her weekly sessions ended. Follow-up usually includes:
- Psychiatrist reviews at 2, 4, 8 and 12 weeks, then monthly, with a repeat PDSS, GAD-7 and PHQ-9 at three and six months
- The SSRI continued for about a year after she felt well, and then stopped slowly, only as her doctor advised
- Booster CBT sessions at three and six months, and extra sessions at any time during a stressful period
- A written relapse-prevention plan with her early warning signs, her exposure practice and the steps to take if an attack came
- Regular practice in the situations she had faced, such as the train, so that the fear did not return through avoidance
- One or two cups of tea or coffee a day, regular meals and sleep, and no return to regular sedative tablets
- A rule that new or different symptoms, such as chest pain on exertion, fainting or breathlessness that is not like her usual attacks, are checked by a doctor
- Support for her husband, with a named person to call
A single panic attack after a long gap does not mean that treatment has failed. It is a signal to use the plan and to contact the team early. See also our page on anxiety disorder.
Outcome: What Recovery Looks Like in Panic Disorder
What changed for Neha over the first six months:
- Panic attacks: from four or five a week at the start to about one milder attack a week by week 8, and none from month five. In month four her train stopped between stations. She felt the first wave, used her skills, and it peaked in about eight minutes and passed.
- Return to the train: in week three she sat on the platform for 20 minutes. By week six she took one station, by week ten she travelled off-peak to Thane, and by month five she was back on her normal peak-hour commute.
- Medicine: the SSRI was well tolerated after the first restless week. She stopped the alprazolam completely by week ten and did not restart it.
- Scores: her PDSS fell from 18 at the start to 9 at three months and 4 at six months. Her GAD-7 fell from 13 to 7 and then 4, and her PHQ-9 from 8 to 3.
- Checking and safety behaviours: she stopped checking her pulse and turned off the heart-rate alerts on her watch. She no longer carried a water bottle everywhere, and she sat wherever there was a seat.
- Caffeine and sleep: she kept to two cups a day at most and slept through most nights.
- Health care use: no emergency room visits in the six months.
- Family: her husband said he had stopped being her driver and had his wife back. Neha said, “The fear still comes sometimes, but now I know what it is.”
It is worth being clear about what recovery means. Most people with panic disorder improve a great deal with treatment, but this is not a promise that panic will never return. Recovery means that attacks are rare, mild and understood, that fear no longer decides where the person goes, and that the person knows what to do if one comes. Some people need a longer course, a change of medicine or more sessions, and the plan is adjusted to the person.
What the first six months of panic disorder treatment usually look like
- Weeks 1 to 2: assessment, a review of heart and blood reports, an explanation of panic, caffeine reduction and the start of medicine if advised.
- Weeks 3 to 12: weekly CBT with interoceptive and graded exposure, daily practice at home, medicine review and a slow reduction of any sedative tablets.
- Months 3 and 4: fewer sessions, harder exposure tasks such as peak-hour travel, and a return to full work duties.
- Months 5 and 6: booster sessions, a repeat of the rating scales and a written relapse-prevention plan, with the medicine continued.
This is a general guide. Every person moves at a different pace, and the treating team decides the plan and the follow-up.
Key Takeaways from This Panic Disorder Case Study
- A panic attack is a sudden surge of intense fear with strong body symptoms that peaks within minutes. It feels like a heart attack, but it does not damage the heart.
- Chest pain, a racing heart or breathlessness should always be checked by a doctor first, especially the first time or if the symptoms are different from usual.
- Panic disorder means repeated attacks with fear of the next one or changes in behaviour to avoid it. Avoiding trains, lifts and crowds can grow into agoraphobia.
- Avoidance, checking and sedative tablets bring short relief but keep the cycle going.
- The first-line treatment is CBT with exposure to body sensations and feared places, often with an SSRI medicine.
- Benzodiazepines are not a good long-term answer and should be reduced slowly, only under a doctor’s guidance.
- Cutting down caffeine, keeping a sleep routine and staying active help.
- Most people improve a great deal. A single attack later on does not mean treatment has failed.
When Should You See a Doctor?
Please speak to a doctor or psychiatrist if you or someone you know:
- Has sudden attacks of intense fear with a racing heart, chest tightness, sweating, shaking or breathlessness
- Lives in constant fear of the next attack, or checks their pulse or body again and again
- Avoids trains, lifts, crowds, driving or being alone because of panic
- Has been to the emergency room several times with normal tests and still fears that something is wrong
- Uses alcohol, sedative tablets or a lot of caffeine to get through the day
- Feels low, hopeless or unable to enjoy life because of the fear
If you have chest pain, a racing heart or breathlessness for the first time, or if the symptoms are different from your usual attacks, such as pain on exertion, fainting, or pain spreading to the arm or jaw, get medical care at once or call 112. Do not assume that it is panic. If anyone talks about ending their life or cannot stay safe, call 112 or Tele-MANAS on 14416 and stay with them until help arrives. You can also call our 24-hour helpline for a confidential conversation.
Panic Disorder Case Study: Frequently Asked Questions
What is panic disorder?
Panic disorder is an anxiety disorder in which a person has repeated, sudden panic attacks and lives in fear of the next one, or changes their behaviour to avoid it. It is diagnosed by a doctor after other causes of the symptoms have been ruled out.
What is the difference between a panic attack and panic disorder?
A panic attack is a single wave of intense fear that peaks within minutes. Many people have one or two in their lives. Panic disorder is diagnosed when attacks keep coming, often without a clear trigger, and the fear of another attack or the avoidance that follows lasts for a month or more.
Can a panic attack be mistaken for a heart attack?
Yes, very often. Both can cause chest pain, a racing heart, sweating and breathlessness. A panic attack does not damage the heart, but the first time these symptoms appear, or if they are different from your usual attacks, they should be checked by a doctor at once.
What are the symptoms of a panic attack?
Common symptoms are a pounding heart, chest tightness, shortness of breath, sweating, trembling, dizziness, tingling in the hands and face, nausea, a feeling of unreality and a strong fear of dying or losing control.
How long does a panic attack last?
A panic attack usually peaks within about ten minutes and passes within 20 to 30 minutes, although it can feel much longer. Learning that the wave rises and falls on its own is a key part of treatment.
What causes panic disorder?
There is usually no single cause. A tendency to be sensitive to body sensations, family history, long-term stress, a major life change, too much caffeine, alcohol or drug use, and other conditions such as thyroid disease or depression can all play a part.
Can panic disorder be cured?
Most people improve a great deal with the right treatment, and many have no attacks for long periods. Because stress can bring panic back, doctors usually speak of control and recovery rather than a guaranteed cure. A single attack later does not mean that treatment has failed.
How is panic disorder treated?
The main treatments are cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) with exposure to feared body sensations and situations, and medicines such as SSRIs. Lifestyle steps such as less caffeine, regular sleep and exercise also help. The treating team chooses the plan for each person.
Are sedative tablets like alprazolam a good treatment for panic disorder?
They can calm an attack quickly, but they are not recommended as a long-term treatment because they can keep avoidance going and lead to dependence. They should be used only on a doctor’s advice and should not be stopped suddenly if taken regularly.
What is agoraphobia and how is it linked to panic disorder?
Agoraphobia is a fear of places or situations where escape or help might be hard, such as trains, crowds, lifts or being outside alone. Many people develop it after panic attacks because they start to avoid the places where an attack happened.
How is panic disorder managed at Calida Rehab?
After a medical review, our team gives a clear explanation of panic, CBT with exposure, medicine where needed, a safe plan to reduce sedative tablets and caffeine, family support and written follow-up. Most people begin with a short stay for assessment and the start of therapy, followed by planned follow-up.
Is my information kept private?
Yes. Assessment and treatment details are confidential and are shared with family or employers only with your consent.
Sources and Further Reading
This page is for information and is not a substitute for medical advice. The case described is a composite example, and details are illustrative. Chest pain, a racing heart or breathlessness for the first time needs a medical check. If anyone is at risk of self-harm, call 112 or Tele-MANAS on 14416.
- American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition, Text Revision (DSM-5-TR). 2022.
- World Health Organization. International Classification of Diseases, 10th Revision (ICD-10), F41.0 Panic disorder; F40.01 Agoraphobia with panic disorder.
- American Psychiatric Association. Practice Guideline for the Treatment of Patients With Panic Disorder, Second Edition. 2009.
- National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. Generalised anxiety disorder and panic disorder in adults: management (CG113). 2011.
- Shear MK, Brown TA, Barlow DH, et al. Multicenter collaborative Panic Disorder Severity Scale. American Journal of Psychiatry, 1997; 154(11): 1571-1575.
- Spitzer RL, Kroenke K, Williams JBW, Lowe B. A brief measure for assessing generalized anxiety disorder: the GAD-7. Archives of Internal Medicine, 2006; 166(10): 1092-1097.
- Kroenke K, Spitzer RL, Williams JBW. The PHQ-9: validity of a brief depression severity measure. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 2001; 16(9): 606-613.
- Craske MG, Barlow DH. Mastery of Your Anxiety and Panic, 4th ed. Oxford University Press, 2006.